Essential reading for the healthcare business
Remember me:
Skip Navigation LinksHealthInvestor article
Advertorial: What’s app, Doc?

Alex Kafetz, managing partner and director of insight and strategy at healthcare communications consultancy ZPB Associates, considers the future of digital GP consultations

It’s been around four years since a number of equity-backed companies entered the digital primary care market, all making video consultations with general practitioners (GPs) available to NHS patients. It is estimated that at least eight to 10 million patients in England have the option of consulting with their GP over a video app. The uptake is just a fraction of these numbers.

There are two market models emerging. The first, used by providers such as Push Doctor (which ZPB advises), Livi and others, is video consultation within a patient’s existing practice, meaning these individuals don’t need to change GPs and register with a new practice.

This minimises disruption for the patient and offers better access and choice, but it makes the cost of patient acquisition high and relies on GP practices to promote the service. Accessing the GP can be clunky, and patients need to download an app and prove their identity before speaking to the GP. 

The second option, including Babylon’s GP at Hand, involves a digital-first approach where patients (if eligible), leave their existing practice to join a new one. There are face-to-face consultations, but the trade-off for the patient is that these may take place some distance from their home. The provider has effectively set up a new GP practice and so receives full NHS per capita funding for every patient regardless of whether they ever have an appointment. Their acquisition cost is comparably lower, and the patient is actively encouraged to take a digital consultation at (almost) all times. Initial analysis of these models indicates ‘buyer’s remorse’ with a high number of people signing up, but being unaware that they need to leave their GP (1). Also, careful consideration must be given to leaving the existing practices which might not take you back. Women considering starting a family or people at risk of developing chronic conditions may not want to take the risk of losing the option of easy local face-to-face appointments.

A consequence of this model is that many patients registered at the digital-first practice don’t live within the area covered by the host clinical commissioning group (CCG). This is the first example I can think of, since 2012, that the ambitions and success of a practice could seriously deviate from those of the host CCG. For example, the CCG may have very low rates for early detection of cancer and prioritise its GPs to improve this outcome. While the digital-first practice may be excellent at doing this, it does not improve figures for the CCG if the majority of its patients are out of area. NHS England’s digital first consultation (2) is looking to address some of these issues.

For both models, interoperability of records is a must, meaning the GP on video can access and write into the patient’s notes.

The bifurcation of the market is actually a good thing and offers different options to patients, all with the assurance that this is NHS funded care. Diversity in the providers’ business models will bring a degree of longevity and choice to the marketplace.

One thing that still needs to be addressed is any widening of health inequalities, especially for those with low data packages on their mobile devices that they may not want to use up on healthcare. Network providers are now offering packages whereby customers can stream movies or watch sport without affecting their paid-for allowance. An easy win for the NHS would be to negotiate a similar arrangement with the main network suppliers for accredited apps. Whichever parts of the market succeed, it seems that finally those who want to access their primary care digitally will find options in their local area very soon.


ZPB Associates advises, positions and steers organisations through the complexities of the UK health and care system. Their clients are forward-thinkers in pharma, tech, data and service providers.


Posted on: 20/11/2019

Latest news stories

In Scotland, more people have died from Covid-19 in care homes than in hospital, according to the latest official figures.
UK primary care REIT Assura is set to start work this month on a new GP surgery in Ware, Hertfordshire.
Elysium Neurological, part of Elysium Healthcare, has opened a specialised neurobehavioural rehabilitation service for adults in Swindon.
DenScreen, a partnership between dental and infectious disease experts, has launched a new service to tackle and minimise the risk of Covid-19 in the dental workplace.
The government’s abrupt decision announced at the weekend that 2.2 million people in England with medical conditions that put them at greater risk from Covid-19 can now leave their homes has left patients anxious and confused.

HealthInvestor blog
April was indeed the cruellest month, to paraphrase T.S.Eliot. The tragedy of so many lives lost will resonate for decades and we will long remember the bitter chill from the sinister shadow of Covid-19.

Click here to view the HealthInvestor blog

We could be forgiven for failing to remember that Brexit happened just four short months ago but the implications for the sector are still very much here to stay. Marie Manley and Will Holmes, of Sidley Austin investigate the future for life sciences
Helen Costa is the founder of Cornerstone, a social enterprise focused on improving the lives of children and families touched by the care system. She talks to Jenna Lomax about challenging the consultancy industry and how virtual reality can improve vulnerable lives
Helen Nugent, a barrister in the clinical negligence team at Temple Garden Chambers, outlines what operators need to know about the provision and use of PPE at a time of crisis
With the technologies now available to us, there is no reason government initiatives to track and control the spread of Covid-19 must come at the expense of personal data privacy, writes R3’s Isabelle Corbett
The Covid-19 outbreak has had a significant impact on the UK healthcare real estate investment market. Kathy Oxtoby reviews the landscape

Click here to search all feature articles

my images

Social care

Helen Costa is the founder of Cornerstone, a social enterprise focused on improving the lives of children and families touched by the care system. She talks to Jenna Lomax about challenging the consultancy industry and how virtual reality can improve vulnerable lives
Read more

Christie + Co

Investment amid Covid-19
The Covid-19 virus has put the fragility of the global economic system under the microscope. But Jenna Lomax finds out why some leading industry figures believe the healthcare sector will be able to quickly bounce back from the economic freeze
Read more